Johor Signal.my
Updated 7 Nov 2026

Twin-CityBenchmark

Can Johor catch up with Singapore? Four other borders have tried. Here is how far each got, how long it took, and what it would take for Johor.

The measure throughout is output per person (GDP per head). We express it as a gap: how many times more the richer side produces per person. A gap of 8.8× means that for every US$1 of output per Johorean, Singapore produces US$8.80.

Last update 01.11.2026 · Currency: US$ at annual average rates

The answer in three lines

  1. Johor starts from the widest gap: 8.8×Singapore produces 8.8 times more per person than Johor. That is the widest of the five rich–poor borders tracked here.
  2. Only Shenzhen has closed a gap this wideIt went from about 12× behind Hong Kong in 1979 to 1.9× in 2025, which took 46 years of very fast growth. Tijuana, after 60 years, is still at 5.4×.
  3. Johor is catching up in ringgit, not in dollarsSince 2010 Johor's income per person has grown faster than Singapore's in local money. A weaker ringgit has more than cancelled that out.
8.8×
Singapore's GDP per head over Johor's, 2025. Widest of the five pairs.
6.1×
Singapore's median monthly pay over Johor's, 2025.
~300k
People crossing Johor's two land links on a typical day. An estimate; no official count exists.
RM110bn
Approved investment in Johor in 2025, the highest of any Malaysian state.
Step 1

Where Johor stands

Each border plotted by how long it has been integrating and how close the poorer side has come to the richer one.

The catch-up chart

Poorer side's output per person, as a share of the richer side's. Higher means closer to catching up.

X axis: years since each border's starting point (Shenzhen 1979, the year before the SEZ; Iskandar Malaysia 2006; Batam growth triangle 1989; maquiladoras 1965; Øresund Bridge 2000). Nominal US$. Shenzhen's line between its two measured points is a smoothed path at its average convergence rate, not annual data. Sources in Method.
Step 2

Why Johor's gap grew

Between 2010 and 2025 the gap widened from 6.9× to 8.8×. Splitting the change in two shows that Johor's economy was not the cause.

What moved the gap, 2010 to 2025

Singapore's GDP per head over Johor's, in US$. Green narrows the gap; amber widens it.

Gap in 2010US$6,849 vs US$47,237
6.9×
Johor grew faster−8.3 log points, in local money
−0.5×
Ringgit weakened against S$+32.8 log points
+2.5×
Gap in 2025US$11,220 vs US$98,886
8.8×
0×2×4×6×8×10×
Johor: DOSM GDP per capita, RM22,035 (2010) and RM48,031 (2025). Singapore: World Bank via FRED, US$47,237 (2010); SingStat S$129,194 (2025). Exchange rates: Federal Reserve G.5A annual averages. The two effects multiply: 6.90 × 0.92 × 1.39 = 8.81.
Step 3

What it would take

Set the growth rates yourself and see when Johor would reach Tijuana's gap today (5.4×) or Shenzhen's (1.9×).

Johor's and Singapore's nominal income growth, and the ringgit's slide against the Singapore dollar, all at their 2010–2025 averages.

Per year, in ringgit.
Per year, in Singapore dollars.
Per year. Negative means the ringgit weakens, as it did by about 2.2% a year from 2010 to 2025.

The gap, projected

Singapore's output per person over Johor's. Log scale, so equal steps mean equal percentage changes.

10×Gap in 2035
12×Gap in 2045
NeverJohor reaches Tijuana's 5.4× gap
NeverJohor reaches Shenzhen's 1.9× gap

At these rates the gap keeps widening, to 12× by 2045. Johor's edge over Singapore, after currency moves, is −1.6 points a year. Halving the gap by 2045 needs an edge of about 3.5 points a year.

For economists

The convergence model

The same story in the language of growth economics: β-convergence, half-lives and a decomposition of the gap.

Convergence on a pair of regions (β model)Two-point estimates · nominal US$ unless stated

Set-up

Let Gt = ln(yrich / ypoor) be the log gap in GDP per head. Conditional β-convergence says the gap decays at a constant proportional rate:

dG/dt = −β·G  ⇒  Gt = G0·e−βt  ⇒  β = ln(G0/GT) / T

Two consequences. The half-life of the log gap is t½ = ln2 / β. And the growth edge the poorer side needs is not constant: it equals β·Gt, so it is largest at the start, when the gap is widest.

gpoor − grich = β·Gt  ·  Johor today: β·ln 8.81 = β × 2.18

At the textbook β of 2% a year, Johor would need to outgrow Singapore by 4.4 points a year now. At Shenzhen's β it would need 6.3.

Decomposing the change in the gap

With incomes Y in local currency and e the ringgit price of one Singapore dollar, the US$ gap is (YSG/YJ)·e. In logs, changes add up exactly:

ΔGUS$ = Δln(YSG/YJ) + Δln e
+24.5 = −8.3 + 32.8  (log points, 2010–2025)

Estimated rates of convergence

PairWindowβ a yearHalf-life
Shenzhen–Hong KongUS$1979–20252.89%24 yrs
Johor–SingaporeUS$2010–2025-0.80%Diverging
Johor–Singapore2025 exchange rate held fixed2010–20250.25%279 yrs
Textbook benchmarkBarro & Sala-i-MartinRegions, many studies2.00%35 yrs

Projections for Johor from 2025

Assumed βReach 5.4×Reach 2×Edge needed now
β = 2% (textbook)203813 yrs208257 yrs4.4 pts
β = 2.9% (Shenzhen)20349 yrs206540 yrs6.3 pts
β = 0.25% (Johor 2010–25, fixed FX)2127102 yrsAfter 2300460 yrs0.5 pts

Caveats

  • Two points are not a regression. Each β uses only the first and last observation, so there are no standard errors. Annual series would allow a proper panel estimate.
  • Nominal, not real. As a poorer region converges its prices rise too (the Balassa–Samuelson effect), so nominal gaps close faster than real ones. A PPP comparison would show a narrower Johor–Singapore gap.
  • Units differ. Johor is a whole state, rural districts included. Shenzhen, Batam and San Diego are cities or counties. Johor Bahru alone would sit higher on the catch-up chart.
  • Survivorship. Shenzhen is the best-known success among China's SEZs. Using it as the benchmark sets a high bar.
  • Rebasing. DOSM's 2010 and 2015 state figures use the 2010 base year and 2025 uses the 2015 base. The effect on nominal per-head levels is small.
Explore the pairs

All five borders

The snapshot behind the steps above, with pay as a second measure. Select a pair to open its profile.

The gap ladder

How many times larger the richer side is, on output per person and on typical pay.

Richer side ÷ poorer side, nominal US$. A value of 1× means parity. Pay measures differ by pair; see Method.

Pair profiles

Both sides of each border, with the zone's set-up, the flows across it and what it suggests for JS-SEZ.

Johor–Singapore

Johor–Singapore Special Economic Zone. Agreement signed 7 January 2025, covering nine flagship zones across 3,588 km² of southern Johor.

8.8×GDP per head gap
6.1×Monthly pay gap

Singapore Richer side · City-state

GDP per head, 2025 official
US$98,886S$129,194
SingStat, National Accounts 2025
Typical monthly pay official
US$3,827S$5,000
Median gross monthly income, full-time residents, excluding employer CPF, 2025MOM, Labour Force in Singapore 2025Median excluding employer CPF (Dollars and Sense, from MOM)
FDI inflows 2025, national
US$150.9bnSingapore
ASEAN Investment, WIR 2026 figures for ASEAN

Johor Poorer side · State

GDP per head, 2025 official
US$11,220RM48,031
DOSM, Johor GDP 2025 (Jul 2026)
Typical monthly pay official
US$628RM2,688
Median monthly salary and wage, Malaysian citizens, 2025DOSM Salaries & Wages Survey 2025, state medians
FDI inflows 2025, national
US$15.4bnMalaysia, RM65.9bn (DOSM)
DOSM, FDI in Malaysia 2025
Regional investment
RM110bn approved investment in Johor in 2025 (about US$25.7bn, domestic and foreign), the highest of any stateInvest Johor / MIDA, approved investments 2025
Across the border estimate
~300,000people a day

Cross the Causeway and Second Link on a typical day, as cited by the Johor state government. Immigration records gave 295,731 a day in 2015. There is no official count of commuters.

How the zone is set up
  • Two land links: the Causeway and the Second Link (1998)
  • RTS Link rail shuttle targeted to open by end-2026
  • Nine flagship zones, from Iskandar Puteri to Desaru
What to watch

The widest gap of the five pairs. Wide gaps drive commuting and cost-saving investment. The test for JS-SEZ is whether realised investment and Johor-based pay rise, rather than only approvals and crossings.

All five, side by side

The same indicators in one table. Copy it as CSV to use in your own analysis.

PairGDP/head, richGDP/head, poorGDP gapPay, richPay, poorPay gapBorder flowZone set-up
Johor–SingaporeSingapore / Johor · 2025 US$98,886US$11,2208.8× US$3,827US$6286.1× ~300,000 people a dayestimate JS-SEZ
Shenzhen–Hong KongHong Kong / Shenzhen · 2025 US$56,994US$29,7411.9× US$2,719US$2,2191.2× ~750,000 crossings a dayofficial Shenzhen SEZ
Copenhagen–MalmöCapital Region / Skåne · 2024 US$98,035US$48,6082.0× US$8,735US$4,2522.0× ~22,000 commutersofficial Øresund region
Batam–SingaporeSingapore / Batam · 2025 US$98,886US$11,8738.3× US$3,827US$29013.2× 1.29m foreign arrivals, Jan–Oct 2025official Batam FTZ
San Diego–TijuanaSan Diego County / Baja California · 2024 US$100,957US$18,6825.4× US$6,561US$1,1415.8× ~90,000 northbound crossings a dayofficial Maquiladora corridor

Five readings for Johor

What the comparison suggests. These are interpretations of the figures above, offered for discussion.

Johor starts from the widest gap

Singapore's output per head is 8.8 times Johor's, the widest of the five pairs and slightly wider than Singapore–Batam. Part of this is geography: the figure covers the whole state, rural districts included, while Batam, Shenzhen and San Diego are city or county units. Johor Bahru district alone would show a narrower gap.

8.8× Johor · 8.3× Batam · 5.4× Tijuana · 2.0× Øresund · 1.9× Shenzhen

Convergence is possible, and slow

Shenzhen became a special economic zone in 1980. In 1979 its output per head was about a twelfth of Hong Kong's; by 2025 it was about half, and the average pay of workers in state and large firms comes close to Hong Kong's median. Most of the 274 million border crossings in 2025 were made by Hong Kong, Macau and Taiwan residents, so the traffic now runs both ways.

~12× in 1979 → 1.9× in 2025 · β ≈ 2.9% a year · 750,000 crossings a day

Factories alone do not close the gap

Tijuana has hosted export assembly plants since Mexico's maquiladora programme began in 1965. Baja California still produces about a fifth of San Diego County's output per head, and its average formal wage is about a sixth of San Diego's. Proximity brought jobs; higher local pay needs skills, local suppliers and firms that design their own products.

5.4× GDP gap · 5.8× pay gap · 60 years of maquiladoras

Count the people, not only the vehicles

Denmark and Sweden match tax registers to count every cross-border commuter, quarter by quarter: about 22,000 in 2024. For Johor–Singapore, the most-cited figure, around 300,000 people a day, is an estimate. JS-SEZ has no official commuter statistic, which makes building one a clear research and policy opportunity.

Official register (Øresund) vs estimate (JS-SEZ)

A land link is Johor's edge over Batam

Batam's income level is close to Johor's, and it has courted Singapore manufacturers for decades. But Batam is a ferry ride away, so most of its cross-border flow is visitors: about 1.29 million foreign arrivals in the first ten months of 2025, against roughly 300,000 people a day crossing Johor's two land links. The RTS Link, targeted to open by the end of 2026, adds rail capacity that no other Singapore neighbour has.

~4,200 foreign arrivals a day (Batam) vs ~300,000 daily crossers (Johor)

Method & sources

How the figures were built, and where they fall short.

How the comparison works

  • GDP per head is at current prices in local currency, from each statistics office, for the latest year available. Both sides of a pair use the same year: 2025 for Johor–Singapore, Shenzhen–Hong Kong and Batam–Singapore; 2024 for Øresund and San Diego–Tijuana.
  • Local values are converted to US dollars at annual average exchange rates (US Federal Reserve G.5A; the rupiah from the 2025 average reported by CIMB Niaga). Gaps are nominal, not adjusted for prices, so they overstate differences in living standards.
  • Units: Johor state, Singapore, Shenzhen city, Hong Kong, the Capital Region of Denmark, Skåne county, Batam city, San Diego County and Baja California state. San Diego's per-head figure divides BEA county GDP by the population implied by BEA's own per-person series.
  • Pay is not like-for-like. Singapore, Johor and Hong Kong use medians; Shenzhen, Denmark, Sweden, Riau Islands, San Diego and Baja California use averages, which sit above medians. Batam uses the Riau Islands provincial average. San Diego pay is May 2024; Baja California pay is 2025.
  • Foreign direct investment is national inflows for 2025 (UNCTAD World Investment Report 2026), except Malaysia, which uses DOSM's balance-of-payments figure converted at the 2025 rate. National figures say little about the border region itself; regional investment is listed where an official figure exists.
  • Steps 1 to 3 add history. Johor 2010 and 2015 use DOSM state GDP per capita at the Federal Reserve annual rate; Singapore uses World Bank US$ figures. Shenzhen 1979 is ¥606 per head (UN-Habitat) at the official rate of ¥1.555 per US$, set against Hong Kong's US$4,569 (World Bank). Convergence rates (β) are two-point estimates; see the caveats under For economists. Scenario presets use the 2010–2025 averages and 2025 growth (DOSM, SingStat).
  • Border flows are not comparable across pairs: they count commuters, trips, arrivals or vehicles depending on what each country publishes. The pill on each figure says which.
OfficialPublished by a statistics office or government agency for that exact measure.
DerivedCalculated here from official inputs (conversions, per-head, monthly from daily or hourly).
EstimateA widely cited figure without an official count behind it.

Exchange rates used

Sources

  1. DOSM, Johor GDP 2025 (Jul 2026)
  2. SingStat, National Accounts 2025
  3. MOM, Labour Force in Singapore 2025
  4. Median excluding employer CPF (Dollars and Sense, from MOM)
  5. DOSM Salaries & Wages Survey 2025, state medians
  6. DOSM, FDI in Malaysia 2025
  7. Invest Johor / MIDA, approved investments 2025
  8. Malay Mail, Johor MB on 300,000 daily commuters (2023)
  9. Johor state assembly, Immigration count of 295,731 a day (2016)
  10. LTG, RTS Link timeline
  11. Shenzhen Statistics Bureau, 2025 Statistical Bulletin
  12. Shenzhen Statistics Bureau, 2025 average wages
  13. Shenzhen border inspection, 274m crossings in 2025 (HK01)
  14. HKSAR Budget 2026, Economic Performance in 2025
  15. C&SD, Annual Earnings and Hours Survey 2025
  16. Statistics Denmark, NRHP regional GDP per inhabitant
  17. Statistics Denmark, LONS30 earnings by region
  18. Statistics Sweden, Regional accounts 2024
  19. SCB average monthly pay by region (Dagens PS, Jul 2026)
  20. Øresundsbron, Øresund Index 2026
  21. Region Skåne, Øresund commuting 2024
  22. BPS via Databoks, Batam GRDP per capita 2025
  23. BPS Sakernas Aug 2025, provincial wages (GoodStats)
  24. BPS Kepri, foreign arrivals Jan–Oct 2025
  25. BEA GDP by County, San Diego (FRED)
  26. USAFacts, San Diego GDP per person (BEA)
  27. BLS OEWS San Diego, May 2024
  28. INEGI PIBE 2024 and population, in SHCP table (DOF)
  29. IMSS average daily wage 2025 (Posta, from El Economista)
  30. Secretaría de Economía, FDI by state 2025 (UnoTV)
  31. BTS, Border Crossing Data Annual Release 2025
  32. UNCTAD, World Investment Report 2026 annex tables
  33. ASEAN Investment, WIR 2026 figures for ASEAN
  34. Top 20 FDI hosts 2025, from WIR 2026
  35. Publimetro, WIR 2026 on Mexico, Hong Kong, China
  36. US Federal Reserve, G.5A annual exchange rates
  37. CIMB Niaga, 2025 average USD/IDR
  38. DOSM, GDP by State 2010–2016 (Johor per capita, 2010 and 2015)
  39. World Bank via FRED, Singapore GDP per capita (US$)
  40. World Bank via FRED, Hong Kong GDP per capita 1979 (US$)
  41. FRED, ringgit per US$ annual average (2010, 2015)
  42. FRED, Singapore dollar per US$ annual average (2010)
  43. UN-Habitat, The Story of Shenzhen (GDP per head ¥606 in 1979)
  44. World Bank, official exchange rate, China (¥1.555 per US$, 1979)
  45. SingStat, GDP 4Q 2025: full-year growth 5.0%
  46. Business Today, DOSM: Johor leads states at 8% growth in 2025
  47. Barro & Sala-i-Martin (1992), Convergence, Journal of Political Economy